ProtectMyMail vs Proton Mail vs Tuta: which fits you?
- Proton Mail and Tuta are separate encrypted email providers — you move to a new inbox and address.
- ProtectMyMail adds encryption to the Gmail/Outlook inbox you already use.
- Switching gives a clean slate; adding-on keeps your address and habits.
- The right choice depends on whether you want to migrate or augment.
There are two honest approaches to private email. You can switch to an encrypted provider, or you can protect the inbox you already use. Proton Mail and Tuta take the first path; ProtectMyMail takes the second.
Proton Mail & Tuta: switch providers
Both are well-regarded encrypted email services with their own apps and infrastructure. You get a new encrypted mailbox and address, with strong defaults.
The trade-off is migration: a new address to share, contacts and filters to move, and getting the people you email onto compatible encryption for full end-to-end coverage.
ProtectMyMail: keep your inbox
ProtectMyMail is a browser plugin that adds end-to-end encryption, verified senders and optional threat scanning (coming soon) inside Gmail, Outlook or IMAP. You keep your address, your inbox and your habits, and encrypt the messages that matter.
The trade-off is that you are building on top of a mainstream provider rather than replacing it — good if migration isn't realistic for you.
Which should you choose?
- Choose a new provider (Proton/Tuta) if you want a clean, privacy-first mailbox and are willing to migrate.
- Choose ProtectMyMail if switching addresses isn't practical and you want to protect the inbox you already depend on.
They are not mutually exclusive philosophies — both accept that ordinary email isn't private and try to fix it. The difference is migrate versus augment.
Frequently asked
Is adding encryption as secure as a dedicated provider?
For the messages you encrypt, the end-to-end model is the same: only you and your recipient can read them. Dedicated providers additionally control the whole stack.
Can I use ProtectMyMail with a work Gmail/Outlook?
Yes — it works with Gmail, Outlook and IMAP accounts, including many workplace setups, without changing your address.
Keep the inbox you already use — private.
ProtectMyMail adds end-to-end encryption to Gmail, Outlook and IMAP, right in your browser. Start with 4 weeks free, then $5/month.
Add to browser →